Securing Trust in India’s Digital Citizenship

January 22, 2018

Blog

Jai Rajaraman, Vice President and Global Head of Technology

User privacy has been at the forefront of debates over digital identity since their inception.  The case of Aadhaar, the Indian government’s digital identity solution, has attracted particular attention in recent months.  India’s Supreme Court ruled in August of last year that privacy is a fundamental right of Indian citizenship, reigniting legal and political debates over Aadhaar.  Aadhaar has not been deemed a breach of privacy in itself; the case hinged rather on the security and confidentiality of the personal data the system relies on, and to what use that data may be put.

As India pursues its aim to bring about a largely cashless society, digital identity verification will play an increasingly central role in daily life there.  What citizens buy, which publications they read, and where they travel will in time become a matter of record.  Should transit by rail, for instance, come to require one’s Aadhaar number, the state will hold details on every train journey a citizen makes as a matter of course. With subscription to mobile networks in India already requiring verification via Aadhaar, the state would soon be able to link the travel and call records of every individual in the country. These implications have prompted debates across Indian society over proper safeguards on how that data can be used and secured.

Public trust in the solution was not helped by a recent exposé by investigative journalists.  Earlier this month, Indian newspaper The Tribune reported that it had been able to gain access to private identity information belonging to Indian citizens enrolled in Aadhaar, by paying an official at the Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI) around $8.  The official in question also provided, for a further $5, software necessary to print Aadhaar cards on entering the Aadhaar number of any individual – effectively enabling the reporters to clone the digital identity of almost anyone in India.  Sanjay Jindal, Additional Director-General at the UIDAI Regional Centre in Chandigarh, has accepted that these events constitute “a major national security breach.”  The story appears not to end there: the lead reporter working on the report claims she has so far revealed only “the tip of the iceberg” and that there is “much more to come”.

Public confidence in the solution has therefore inevitably been called into question.  While the Indian government faces no easy task, in digitising personal identity in the world’s largest democracy, the bottom line is that consumer trust is vital to uptake and success. The mobile industry can help here.  Mobile network operators have a natural interest in ensuring the privacy of their customers – it is on this relationship of trust that much of their commercial success depends.  Where operators are in the driving seat of identity verification, they will naturally place privacy among their very highest priorities.  With their range of authentication assets, such as the SIM card, strong registration processes, and multiple fraud detection and mitigation processes, mobile operators are uniquely well-positioned to help governments design and operate identity solutions – rather than merely providing them with the architecture via which to run them.  And, as 2017 drew to a close, it had become increasingly clear that operators are collaborating to take the lead in digital identity worldwide, building their expertise in this vital component of connected commerce and civic life.

Operator-led identity solutions like Mobile Connect can offer a robust system of consent management: where for instance the present implementation of Aadhaar sees users merely receiving SMS notification when their data is accessed by an approved party, operators can offer a far more consumer-centric consent mechanism.  By matching users with something they have on their person as a matter of course (their mobile phone), in conjunction with something they know (a PIN), and/or something they are (a biometric scan), Mobile Connect’s design precludes data breaches of the kind exposed by The Tribune.

With rigorous transparency and granularity – for instance data availability on a per-transaction basis – operator-led solutions can act primarily as tools of the user, rather than simply a means of integrating that user into a system over which they have little recourse.  Once users are confident in their level of control over their own data, legal and political roadblocks to connected citizenship can be increasingly removed – and rises in living standards can be realised for millions.

Back

Mobile Connect Workshop Presentations at MWCA Identity Seminar The seminar Mobile Connect Seminar: Reducing Fraud through Secure Authentication and ID Verification Services, brought together h wider mobile ecosystem aiming to prevent fraud b...

Read more | See all Identity Resources

Mobile Connect Workshop Presentation at Mobile 360 Digital Societies i The Mobile Connect workshop: Delivering commercial success through identity services attendees had the opportunity to learn the value and commercial scalability of mobile-based ...

Read more | See all Identity Resources

Distributed Ledger Technology, Blockchains and Identity: A Regulatory This paper provides an overview of the relevant regulations for the use of distributed ledger technologies (DLT) and blockchains for digital identity. Digital identity is the bas...

Read more | See all Identity Resources

Digital Identity: Global Trends and Highlights from the United States Mobile internet traffic now accounts for more than half of all global online traffic, reaching 51.2% of the world’s total this year. There are now 8.8 billion mobile connection...

Read more | See all Identity Resources

Digital Identity: Trends and News in China and South East Asia We are living through an exciting time for digital commerce in Asia. According to the Asian Development Bank, e-commerce in Asia as a whole now makes up around a quarter of all a...

Read more | See all Identity Resources

MWCS18 Identity Innovation Labs Presentations The Identity Innovation Labs at Mobile World Congress Shanghai 2018 were a set of three stand-alone industry discussions on the latest developments in digital identity. Featuring...

Read more | See all Identity Resources

Flash News: Court Curbs India’s ID Programme India’s Supreme Court has upheld the country’s ambitious Aadhaar digital identification programme, but struck down the requirement to link mobile-phone numbers, bank accounts...

Read more | Visit Identity Blog

Key Players Gather in Istanbul as Turkey Reaches Commercial Milestone 2018 has been a year in which e-commerce ceased to be an intriguing novelty in advanced economies, and became very much a fact of everyday life on every continent. The Middle Eas...

Read more | Visit Identity Blog

Flash News: Jump in Mobile Fraud Attacks The number of mobile fraud attacks worldwide rose 24% year-on-year in the first half of 2018, according to ThreatMetrix’s analysis of the 17.6 billion digital transactions moni...

Read more | Visit Identity Blog

Achieving Clarity on the Role of Blockchain in Digital Identity As global commerce moves ever more rapidly online, secure and effective provision of digital identity is becoming the lifeblood of the world economy.  The ability to verify user...

Read more | Visit Identity Blog

Flash News: US Mobile Operators Introduce App Log-In Service The four leading mobile operators in the US – AT&T, Sprint, T-Mobile, and Verizon —demonstrated a single sign-on service for smartphones at the Mobile World Congress ...

Read more | Visit Identity Blog

Digital Identity: Crucial for the Success of Today’s Mobile-First Wo Anatoly Kvitnitsky, VP of Growth, Trulioo Our digital identities are becoming increasingly more important as we transition to a mobile-first world. These identities shape the way...

Read more | Visit Identity Blog

Contact GSMA Legal Email Preference Centre Copyright © 2018 GSMA. GSM and the GSM Logo are registered and owned by the GSMA.